Student Book Reviews

A teacher gets really excited and proud when a class performs well. My heartfelt goal is to produce a class full of young people who truly enjoy reading and writing. This year’s class has been reading voraciously all year. They chose their top 16 books and debated until they chose a winner. Now they’ve written reviews of those top books. Click the REVIEWS tag at the top of the page to see their reviews alongside mine.

I must admit that there were mostly fantasy books in their top 16. Since fantasy is one of my favorites I shouldn’t be surprised. Also, there are a lot of really good fantasy YA books out there. Nonetheless, I am thrilled with their passion for these books. Check out what they have to say and leave your own comment about the book, or about the review.

 

Novel Winner Crowned!

NOVEL MADNESS has come to a close in my classroom today with the final debate over favorite novels. Both by Rick Riordan, Maze of Bones and Lightning Thief are worthy contenders. Both have swept through the classroom like wildfire, and students have kept on reading both series. Student reviews of our top sixteen books will be posted over the next couple of weeks, so come back and check us out! Now on to the announcement.

2012 Novel Madness Winner is

MAZE OF BONES

Maze of Bones is the first book in the 39 Clues series, all of which are written by different authors. Next year, maybe the winner will be my own On a Wing and a Dare.

Semifinal Results Are In!

My sixth grade class is enjoying the tournament of favorites we call NOVEL MADNESS! Today we held the semifinal round, where we pitted Maze of Bones, by Rick Riordan, against Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins. The other battle was between Lightning Thief, also by Rick Riordan, and Unwanteds, by Lisa McCann. The debates raged, bringing up key points in favor of the debater’s novel and slinging a little dirt on the opposition. It turns out we are a Rick Riordan kind of class.

Tomorrow’s FINAL DEBATE will be:

Maze of Bones vs. Lightning Thief

Should we have an Internet vote too? Cast your vote below in a comment! Any vote posted before 8:00 tomorrow morning will be counted in our final tally.

Novel Madness Again

The excitement builds in my classroom! We are down to our top four contenders for the the crown of Favorite Novel. Yesterday’s debates included commentary on the relatability of the characters, quality of vocabulary, genre of the book, and whether it had been made into a movie yet. Most students seem to feel that they can relate best to twelve year olds, as evidenced by Lightning Thief beating out Hunger Games, which has slightly older characters. Discussions about vocabulary included readability–if the vocabulary is easier, more students can enjoy the book. Most interesting to me was the debate over a book being made into a movie. Students seem to agree that only a good book will be made into a movie, but newer books, like Cinder, have not yet had the chance to develop a following. Overall I am impressed with how serious the students are taking this, how well thought out their reasoning is, and how much they are reading!

Here are the results of yesterday’s debates, with winners in red:

Maze of Bones by Rick Riordan vs. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows by J. K. Rowling

Cinder by Marissa Meyers vs. Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins

Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan vs. Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins

Matilda by Roald Dahl vs. Unwanteds by Lisa McMann

Stay tuned for tomorrow’s fireworks as we debate:

Maze of Bones vs. Catching Fire

Lightning Thief vs. Unwanteds

Novel Madness Continues

  As you know, my sixth-grade students are debating their favorite novels. Yesterday they finished eliminating half of their top sixteen. Pairs of students argued for each book. They prepared their pitch and tried to anticipate what their opponent would say against them. They said their piece, then the opponent had one minute to refute. Then the other side went and the original team had one minute to refute. Then the class voted. Here are the results of round 1, with the winners in red:

Unwanteds by Lisa McMann vs. Wednesday Wars by Gary Schmidt

Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins vs. Al Capone Does My Shirts by Gennifer Choldenko

Hex Hall by Rachel Hawkins vs. Matilda by Roald Dahl

Holes by Louis Sachar vs. Cinder by Marissa Meyer

Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan vs. Number the Stars by Lois Lowry

Merchant of Death by D.J. MacHale (Pendragon) vs. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows by J. K. Rowling

Maze of Bones by Rick Riordan (39 Clues) vs. Eragon by Christopher Paolini

Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins vs. Dragon Rider by Cornelia Funke

Stay tuned this week as we crown a winner on Thursday! Feel free to post encouragement for your favorites!

Novel Madness

Even though this is my first year teaching with Reader’s Workshop, my sixth grade students have gotten very excited about reading. I, too, read voraciously. They share books with me and with each other, and I share books with them. So to coincide with March Madness, although I’m starting rather later, I decided to have a novel tournament in my class.

Today, in teams, the students brainstormed the top sixteen novels. These could be old or current favorites. We compiled the team lists into one list. Over the next couple of weeks, we will be holding debates and voting on pairs of books until we have crowned the top novel of the year.

Here are their top sixteen, in no order:

Unwanteds by Lisa McMann

Wednesday Wars by Gary Schmidt

Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins

Al Capone Does My Shirts by Gennifer Choldenko

Hex Hall by Rachel Hopkins

Matilda by Roald Dahl

Holes by Louis Sachar

Cinder by Marissa Meyers

Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins

Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan

Dragon Rider by Cornelia Funke

Eragon by Christopher Paolini

Number the Stars by Lois Lowry

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows by J. K. Rowling

Maze of Bones by Rick Riordan

Merchant of Death by D.J. MacHale

I am impressed by the diversity of titles. The students made an effort to represent their favorite series without overwhelming the list with multiple titles. So although they have both Hunger Games and its sequel, they only have one 39 Clues book (Maze of Bones), one Pendragon book (Merchant of Death), and one Harry Potter book. Two books that we read together in class are included, Al Capone Does My Shirts and Number the Stars, as well as books I discovered and recommended, like Cinder, and books that are new to me like Unwanteds and Wednesday Wars.

I know they had a limited time to come up with titles, but there are some missing that I know they love, like the Narnia series and The Mysterious Benedict Society by Trenton Stewart. Overall, though, I think they did a good job.

Two students have been assigned to each book and are preparing their best persuasive arguments. They will know which book is competing against theirs and will also prepare some rebuttals to what they think the others will say against their books.

So LET THE DEBATES BEGIN!

Like TV With Words

Recently I had the opportunity to interview a variety of students for our school yearbook. The questions ranged from favorite subject to future goals. One young girl responded eagerly when I asked what her favorite subject was. “Reading,” she told me. “It’s like watching TV except you have to read the words.” This is a student I want in my class when she reaches sixth grade!

Visualizing is a key concept in reading, and not all readers do it the same way with every book. If you can see a picture in your head while you read, it makes the text more interesting and more memorable. That, in turn, leads to comprehension. Some books pull the reader in more deeply, and you can visualize scenes as if you were watching a movie. The very best books envelop you so completely that you are actually in the scene. These are the books that make you gasp when the monster jumps out from hiding.

When visualization is taught in the classroom, many teachers have students draw a picture of what comes to mind as they read. This encourages students to pay attention to the setting details so they can draw the background and time of day or season. It also means they have to know which characters are present, and where they are in relation to each other. All of this is very important for understanding the scene.

This is a wonderful beginning, but I want my students to visualize more deeply. They are used to action, to movies and video games that move. I want books to move for them, too. The second stage of visualization is to imagine the story moving before you like a TV show or a movie. Having students draw a comic strip or a storyboard encourages this type of thinking. They can follow the story as the characters move from the park to the library, payin attention to details like how the characters got there. Did they go in a car? Who drove? Understanding character motivation and relationships is important for this type of visualization.

The pinnacle of visualization, however, is dependent upon a wonderfully written book. Some books never reach this level, no matter how hard you try to stuff yourself into them. The best books are the ones where, long after you put them down, you are thinking of yourself interacting with the characters in the scene. While reading, the world around you disappears and the world of the written word surrounds you. If you can read the words and put yourself into the world, you can imagine what is in the scene that the author didn’t tell you about, what should be there based on what you are told. You can hear cars rushing along the streets or smell the heat off the asphalt. Most importantly, when the protagonist faces the antagonist, you wield the sword right next to them. These are the books you remember, and the ones you recommend to your friends with an enthusiastic, “Oh, this was so good!”

The most recent YA books that have been that good for me are Fablehaven by Brandon Mull, Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins, and Cinder by Marissa Myers.

What are the most recent books you’ve read that make you feel that way?

New Reviews Posted!

It’s a busy day for blogging! Check out my reading blog for three new review of YA fantasy books:

Daughter of the Centaurs by Kate Klimo

The Copper Sign by Katia Fox

Twin Souls by DelSheree Gladden

Discovering New Books

    With the release of my novel just two months away, I have suddenly become very interested in how today’s young adults select books to read. When I was younger, I spent many hours in the local public library. Every week I checked out a sizable stack of novels, from early elementary school through high school. It wasn’t until I was out of college and working at a bookstore that I discovered the joy of buying my own books (and I got a 30% discount, too!). But that was the Dark Ages.

To learn more about the reading habits of today’s youth, I started with my own personal focus group: my class of sixth graders. At twelve years old, they are on the younger end of my novel’s target audience, but they are avid readers. First I asked if they selected books themselves or if they read books recommended by parents, teachers, or librarians. While most admitted they had on occasion accepted a recommendation, the vast majority of books they read were self-selected. Standard reasons books were selected didn’t surprise me: the cover illustration and blurb, the author, next book in a series, and genre were all reasons given.

Moving into the twenty-first century, I asked how many used an online source to find books. Many of them have e-readers and have browsed books on Amazon. A handful are members of Goodreads. None of them knew what a blog tour was, yet that seems to be the hottest new way to promote a book (from an author’s point of view). Very few visited book review websites, other than mine, to get ideas for books to read.

So the big question is what about older youth? Do middle school and high school students visit blogs more often? For authors, blog tours are the next hot thing. What about for readers? Chime in if you have a favorite book review site, or if you’ve followed a blog tour hoping for free giveaways.

New book review!

   Click here for 2012 fantasy review #1 for Winterling by Sarah Prineas.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 457 other followers